Friday, February 6, 2009

Life Lessons from Jane Austen's Persuasion

The reason that I love Jane Austen novels and films made from the novels is that she so accurately depicts human nature. A few weeks ago I found myself at the library without my long list of books to read but knew that I was desperate for something good to read, and I knew Miss Austen would not let me down. I decided on Persuasion because I had not yet read it and because I thoroughly enjoyed 2 different film adaptations of it. My two favorite parts are both in the second volume, so the first volume was a little work to get through, knowing how exciting the ending was going to be, but maybe that it had to be that way so the ending would be as exciting.
My first favorite part is at the concert when they finally talk again after eight and a half years and Anne learns that he really doesn't/didn't have feelings for Louisa and that it was that easy for them to fall into an easy conversation and that despite the noise in the room they can still communicate intimately. I love the subtlety of their conversation. His leaving in a fit of jealousy and her realizing it, first relishing it then realizing the danger of him not knowing her true feelings for him only intensifies the reader's desire to read on.
My other favorite part is when he is sitting writing a letter and she is talking to his friend about the differences in the natures of men and women, and he is actually writing a letter to her expressing is love to her. I just love it. I love how they can't talk of their feelings directly to each other so they have to orchestrate a way to say what they mean to say, like how he brought up his friend Benwick's loosing his wife to say,"A man does not recover from such a devotion of the heart to such a woman!" meaning, "I will never get over you. My feelings for you will never change!" And Anne when she is talking with Captain Harville at the window answers him by saying that Fanny Harville, Benwick's deceased wife, never would have forgotten him so soon, because it is not in the nature of a woman, telling Wentworth that, "I will never get over you either!" And she goes further to illustrate that she has actually suffered more than him making grand generalizations about the nature of men and women. All of which leads Wentworth to declare his never ending love in a letter thus opening the lines of communications and allowing her an opportunity to respond openly.

I think the life lesson to learn is to be true to your heart. If she had not been persuaded to turn him down eight and an half years ago, because of his station, and had been true to her heart, she could have avoided a lot of misery for them both. Another lesson is don't try to advise other people who to fall in love with or who to marry, because you will never know the other person's heart. I remember my mom saying something similar when Rebekah first got engaged. She said that she would neither say that she liked nor disliked the person her child was going to marry because if she said she didn't like them and it was actually the person they were supposed to marry, she wouldn't want to have ruined that and on the flip side, she didn't want to say that she liked the person so her child would feel any pressure to marry the person if they were having second thoughts.

6 comments:

Karen Mello Burton said...

Persuasion is my absolute Fave Austen film. The one with Ciaran Hinds is so brilliant! Now I want to go rent it this weekend!

Heidi said...

Yes, I loved the Cairan Hinds version, too. Thanks for satisfying our curiousity so fast, Heather!

Jess said...

k- I am on board as well. Will need to be seeing it soon. Thanks for your insight, so TRUE. It is so hard to be true to your heart when you mind is screaming logic though!

Heidi said...

Thanks for sharing! Persuasion has actually been on my mind a lot lately. It's one I've had to grow to like. When I was first getting into Austen (at 16 or so), the subtleties of the story went right past me.
The letter writing is my favorite part, too. It was so brilliantly worked!
I've been wondering, though, if Anne's decision to break her engagement wasn't the right one after all. The realities of life for a poor sailor's wife were pretty harsh. Marrying for money is obviously not right, but marrying without money is a serious drawback. Look at Fanny Price's mother in Mansfield Park. I guess that's why Jane wrote something about Anne accepting prudence in her youth but becoming romantic as she aged. What do you think?

LisAway said...

I haven't read Persuasion for such a long time, maybe 12 years. I read it twice, I think. My memory is so terrible that I only remember - seriously - one scene, when they are going up/down these steps going up from the boardwalk on the beach or something and the pass each other and make eye contact or something.

Reading your post I vaguely remember the seafaring friend whose wife died. I've never seen any movie of it. And I have to get my hands on a book!

I can't imagine ever wanting to get through any of Austen's books, for the sake of getting to a certain part. I just DRINK IT ALL IN. The stories are wonderful and awesome, of course, but I just love her writing and wit and it's just such a pleasure and I feel like I'm learning something just by reading her words.

Heather said...

Heidi V, good point, about being prudent, but what about all the heart ache?

"Love conquers all, let us surrender to love!" Virgil

Lisa, I didn't mean to imply that I didn't enjoy the beginning of the book, but the anticipation for the other parts was so strong that it made me impatient to get to them, that is how her writing moves me.